I found these coins, are they authentic or remakes of old Chinese coins?

6 berichten • 100 keer bekeken
I found these coins, are they authentic or remakes of old Chinese coins?
my answer is still the same
https://en.numista.com/forum/topic114784.html
Citeer: "alamir"​my answer is still the same
https://en.numista.com/forum/topic114784.html
​your answer was "probably" and it was the only answer I got
You want to post everyday the same pic?
If you want to have your post on the top, write a comment inside.
From the photo they seem to all be Qing Dynasty, so not really old, 17th-19th CE. At first glance they look mostly authentic. Closer examination may prove some to be copies. Your best bet is to look in David Hartill's "Cast Chinese Coins". Just going by your photo, the coin front centre and the one directly behind it seem to be "Qian Long Tong Bao" of Emperor Gao Zong (1736-1795) and the two to the left of those "Kang Xi Tong Bao" of Emperor Sheng Zu (1662-1722). I am not an expert but I have a few from each of these two emperors and I have some modern and contemporary fakes in my collection (almost 1,000 cast Chinese, Japanese, Korean, Vietnamese and Indonesian official coin, coins from private issues, various rebels and Vietnamese and Indonesian 17thC copies of Chinese 10th-12thC Northern Song), so I do have a bit of knowledge and David Hartill's marvelous books. Modern cheap copies made for tourists and Feng Shui are thin, very light and generally have a grainy pattern around the characters. Legitimate coins of the size shown will weigh between 2 and 4.5 grams depending on period and mint they originate from. I hope this is of assistance.
Citeer: "7Bundies"​From the photo they seem to all be Qing Dynasty, so not really old, 17th-19th CE. At first glance they look mostly authentic. Closer examination may prove some to be copies. Your best bet is to look in David Hartill's "Cast Chinese Coins". Just going by your photo, the coin front centre and the one directly behind it seem to be "Qian Long Tong Bao" of Emperor Gao Zong (1736-1795) and the two to the left of those "Kang Xi Tong Bao" of Emperor Sheng Zu (1662-1722). I am not an expert but I have a few from each of these two emperors and I have some modern and contemporary fakes in my collection (almost 1,000 cast Chinese, Japanese, Korean, Vietnamese and Indonesian official coin, coins from private issues, various rebels and Vietnamese and Indonesian 17thC copies of Chinese 10th-12thC Northern Song), so I do have a bit of knowledge and David Hartill's marvelous books. Modern cheap copies made for tourists and Feng Shui are thin, very light and generally have a grainy pattern around the characters. Legitimate coins of the size shown will weigh between 2 and 4.5 grams depending on period and mint they originate from. I hope this is of assistance.
​Thank you

» Forumbeleid

Gebruikte tijdzone is UCT+2:00.
Huidige tijd is 09:00.