Which to keep ?

I have these two and I'm not sure which to keep - I know the poto isn't the best but it's OK. One is shiny like a UNC, the other seems UNC but has changed colour. Which would you keep ?

It's not about shininess.

The one that has the least wear I'd keep. Check the areas of the coin that would have the most wear.

They both are unc mate just looks like one was taken away and encapsulated or flipped and the other has sat in a jar as its only toned no scratches atall on either so in this case it is about shininess lol not sure what to do as shiny coins usually don't appeal to me but the holed Africa coins do like my fed Nigeria penny with its red colour..