Guatemala: ¼ real 1878, km146, 146.1 found (SOLVED) [opgelost]

N#61693

I have my doubts of the existence of the km146a.1? In scwc it's shown, but the image is not a 1878 coin! In numista it's just a copy of the KM catalog, so there is no proof, on internet I didn't find it either: 

Can anybody show an image of the km146a.1?

Thanks in advance

Ole

Hi, Sjoelund!

This isn't the first time this catalog has gotten a photo wrong, but this coin exists, it's just hard to find. In fact, it presents some variations as can be seen in this lot that was put up for auction in 2006.

Kind regards,

Raul

Hi Raul,

The images do not show anything, can you please show just one with the 146a.1?

Hi, Sjoelund!

I didn't understand your last question. All coins are variants of Km-164, including the Km-164.a1. You can click to enlarge the image.

Kind regards,

Raul

This is what I think. Top 3 coins. First is clearly km146 (.900). Second has small wreath (km146a.1). Third has large wreath (km146a.2).

I just did, and you are wrong, they are 146, but not the 146a.1! On the other hand, I found the medium G, so thanks.

I'm on it, I think you're right, but the images are not splendid!

Think I beat ya to it!  😇

Here is the next version, in the meantime, I have my doubts about “small” and “large” wreaths?

You were faster, but maybe not so complete?

Anyway, bedtime in Paris!

I didn't notice the different .835's but see it now.  The a.1 wreath is smaller (shorter height) than the a.2.

Goodnight

Final version, if you agree?

Hi, Sjoelund!

Excellent! It's perfect and well explained. Congratulations on the work and editing.

Kind regards,

Raul

Looks good to me but I have to ask what you are going to do with it?  From SCWC 1801-1900 8th Edition:

This! I'm going to insert in the comments section?

👍although I'd add G to the large, medium, small.  

OK, here you are: