help me identify yongzheng tongbao manchu script [opgelost]

6 berichten • 89 keer bekeken
Detail
Detail

just bought this yongzheng tongbao, having trouble identifying it
diameter: 26 mm
closest I could find: N#41542

I think that you're right, your coin is a Boo-an.
N#41542
https://www.zeno.ru/showgallery.php?cat=5821

 

But the main picture on the Boo-an page is incorrect. It looks more like Boo-jin:
https://www.zeno.ru/showgallery.php?cat=5813

 

There is a Boo-jin page (N#223602), but without images.


So basically the main images from  the Boo-an page should be moved to the Boo-jin page and a new set of main images should be added to Boo-an.

The closest one according to Hartill is 22.160, N# 41542. My opinion is that your coin is not Hartill 22.160 and most probably any Hartill code because it has a square head tong. There is no Boo-an with square head tong and taking that into account your coin is a modern fake or fantacy coin, that is my opinion.

I agree, it's 22.160 and boo an

Status gewijzigd naar Opgelost (Radarouton, 13-mei-2025, 15:52)

Ollisaarinen

The closest one according to Hartill is 22.160, N# 41542. My opinion is that your coin is not Hartill 22.160 and most probably any Hartill code because it has a square head tong. There is no Boo-an with square head tong and taking that into account your coin is a modern fake or fantacy coin, that is my opinion.

Hm, yes, you're right. The head of the tong is different, so it's probably a replica. 

wait, it's fake? well that sucks

» Forumbeleid

Gebruikte tijdzone is UCT+2:00.
Huidige tijd is 21:29.