Incorrect edit to Ronald Reagan medal page [opgelost]

4 berichten • 61 keer bekeken

Dit bericht gaat over: verzoek het wijzigen van een exonumia in de catalogus

Status klaar
Stemmen voor: 0
Stemmen tegen: 0

I have the following medal in my collection for swap and I noticed recently the page was updated incorrectly

 

N#20525

 

The page was previously for the version of the medal without the gold layering. I updated the page at the time adding the Token Catalog reference for additional detail

 

https://tokencatalog.com/token_record_forms.php?action=DisplayTokenRecord&td_id=488627

 

At some point after this, the entire page was updated to display as if the gold layered version is the only version that exists, as there is no page for the non-gold layered version of the medal. It seems like rather then a new page in the catalog being created for the gold layered version, the 2 medals ended up incorrectly combined onto one listing.

 

I am wondering if the powers at be could revert the page back to the original version and move the information for the gold layered version of the medal to a new landing page to keep the info separate. As I have this item for swap, the current condition of the page makes it show a item for swap that I don't actually have.

 

Thanks,

 

Tony

Calling a referee for this:@JLHare 

Catalogue administrator

ajbbarbados

I have the following medal in my collection for swap and I noticed recently the page was updated incorrectly

 

N#20525

 

The page was previously for the version of the medal without the gold layering. I updated the page at the time adding the Token Catalog reference for additional detail

The photos for this medal have been modified multiple times. Some with AA and some with other letters. From the original photos when it was added in 2011 it appears to be possibly the gold layered variety (not a good photo). The next photo added in 2017 were the gold layered variety. Interestingly the Token Catalog was added by another user in 2019.

 

https://tokencatalog.com/token_record_forms.php?action=DisplayTokenRecord&td_id=488627

 

At some point after this, the entire page was updated to display as if the gold layered version is the only version that exists, as there is no page for the non-gold layered version of the medal. It seems like rather then a new page in the catalog being created for the gold layered version, the 2 medals ended up incorrectly combined onto one listing.

I accepted a photo modification and other modification about the gold layer in July/2025. The prior photo appearing to me to have a selective gold layer and the new photos were clearer with the gold layer.

I am wondering if the powers at be could revert the page back to the original version and move the information for the gold layered version of the medal to a new landing page to keep the info separate. As I have this item for swap, the current condition of the page makes it show a item for swap that I don't actually have.

I do not see any requests made in the forums to combine this page with another. Not saying it did not happen I just cannot find any requests. Since this page's photos have been changed multiple times here is my suggestion. You create a new page without the gold layer. Be sure to make a general comment on your new submission about there being different varieties with and without the gold layer. Add a link to the current page and after your submission I will add the same comments to this page along with a link to your new page. This should hopefully prevent future issues with any request to combine pages. I will then request all current member be moved to undetermined on the current page so that any confusion from the different varieties can be corrected by each member that has added this to their collection.

 

I hope you find this solution satisfactory to the situation. If I can be of any further help just let me know.

 

Jerry

Referee for Exonumia from United States

Hello Jerry,

 

I have made a new entry for the non-Gold faced version of the medal, and have made some minor alterations to the Gold layered medal page to correct some info and to hopefully help make the pages a bit more distinguishable from one another. 

 

Thank you again for taking the time to follow up on this so thoroughly.

 

Cheers,

 

Tony 

Status gewijzigd naar klaar (Jarcek, 8-nov-2025, 23:07)

» Forumbeleid

Gebruikte tijdzone is UCT+2:00.
Huidige tijd is 21:44.