St Blais Tallero 1971 reproduction wrong date [opgelost]

6 berichten • 37 keer bekeken

Dit bericht gaat over: verzoek het wijzigen van een exonumia in de catalogus

Status klaar
Stemmen voor: 1
Stemmen tegen: 0

The pictured St Blaze Dubrovnik Tallero 1971 reproduction is identified as being from 1733, but it is actually from 1735 (N#18934) . I know because PCGS made the same mistake for mine and they are now correcting it. 

Change it yourself.  Provide your evidence in the Sources box at the bottom.

 

When talking about specific catalog entries always provide a link!

N#18934 

 

If you mean the obverse description, there doesn’t need to be a date at all. Just something like ‘Bust of so and so holding this and that facing right etc.’ and this can be done with a user change request.

If you mean the year lines that currently display 1971 should display 1735 (1971) that can't be changed by a user and in the case of the owned year lines not even by a referee, you would need a catalog admin for that (which this ticket is appropriate for).

I understood he meant this:

 

Maybe I was wrong.

What I mean is this: Currently whereever the text states that the displayed coin is 1733 needs to be changed to say it is 1735. 

 

I have the exaxt same coin as this and PCGS made the same mistake, mistakenly thinking the 5 was a 3.

 

Both Heritage Auctions and PCGS agree it is 1735 and not 1733, PCGS is currently in the process of changing the date on slab but has not fully completed it yet. Heritage has already shown the date to be 1735 for my coin on their website. 

That's exactly correct. The engraver back in Ragusa in the 1700's did not do a good job on his portrayal of the number 5, it can easily be mistaken for a 3. The reproduction shows the exact same thing. 

 

"The documentation that came with my coin when I bought it in Dubrovnik back in 1973 was in SerboCroatian and I had ChatGPT translate it: ""Silver Thaler of the Republic of Dubrovnic, 1735. It is confirmed that this reproduction, with a diameter of 44mm and a weight of 28 g, is minted in silver (566/1000) in a limited edition of 5000 pieces."

Status gewijzigd naar klaar (Jarcek, 5-feb-2026, 13:35)

» Forumbeleid

Gebruikte tijdzone is UCT+2:00.
Huidige tijd is 15:29.