Remove empty/meaningless items in the list of years [opgelost]

6 berichten • 47 keer bekeken

Dit bericht gaat over: het aanvragen van de wijziging van een munt in de catalogus

Status klaar
Stemmen voor: 3
Stemmen tegen: 0

N#38507

 

 

Hi,
Does anyone know the meaning of the first 5 items in the list of years?!..
In my opinion, this is some informational garbage. So please remove these items.

 

For coins with an unreadable date, there is an item “ND (1494–1516)”.

If there is a version where no year was added yes, if it's just unreadable due to condition or out of flan they should be moved to ‘undetermined’.

 

Looks to me like someone wanted to remove year lines but (of course) failed deleting information in the process and with yearlines changes not being tracked (or at least not visible even for referees) who knows what these lines once where.

The design of these coins suggests a date.
For all coins with an undetermined date (out of flan / bad condition), there should only be 1 item. 
I don't know how to name this item ("ND" / "Undetermined" / "ND 1494–1516"). But it should be only 1 item (not 2 items - "Undetermined" and "ND 1494–1516").

From March 2023

From July 2025

So someone just renamed the AH814/818/819 lines instead of removing them?

SGreg85

So someone just renamed the AH814/818/819 lines instead of removing them?

"Removing" is more than just removing, it implies the transfer of user entries.

 

The referee noticed a mismatch, did a quick fix, added a note, and put it off for later... 1 year have passed...😊

Status gewijzigd naar klaar (tdziemia, 14-apr-2026, 03:00)

» Forumbeleid

Gebruikte tijdzone is UCT+2:00.
Huidige tijd is 04:23.