Two Zhou round coins China - genuine or not?

Hi

I do have two examples of Zhou Round coins
State of Qi 330-220 b.c, City of yi 6 hua.

Hartill 6.25  Schjöytt 70 or 71.

I wish for genuine coins , but arent sure.

What do you say?



first one 31 mm 10,16 grams
second one 35 mm 10,30 grams

Niclas

I doubt it.  It seems to be a modern replica (aka "fake") coin.  The calligraphy seems to be off and the variability of the size and weight is another factor against it...