vrai ou faux? ANNAM'S COINS COLLECTION (is it a copy?)

je viens d'acheter ce lot "Annam's coins collection" dans un magasin;
je suppose que ce sont des copies mais certaines sont vraiment bien "vieillies"
du coup je me pose la question.
qu'en pensez vous?
les 2 grosses pièces CANH HUNG sont en faite la même pièce est mesure 41mm.
c'est la plus jolie mais du coup, je pense sûrement la plus fausse.
je ne la trouve nul par, je ne sais même pas quel est sa valeur? 1 Cash?

merci
Beny

Je ne crois pas que ce sont des faux. La plupart des pièces de monnaie en espèces ne sont pas extrêmement précieux . Puis-je demander , combien avez-vous payé pour cela? J'espère ne pas vous offenser .

non pas du tout, j'ai acheté le tout 30euro, les autres collection que j'ai trouvé sur le net, étaient bien plus cher d'ailleurs et elles étaient plus récentes.

;) Hi
I don't speak French or Vietnamese but I've got the same POS! Slightly different though... Yours looks bigger!

None of these coins are fake, but cleaned and glued and sold wholesale to tourists.

Thank you Kenny! I remember your have commented on my post before. But what can you do with these coins? Put the folder on a bookshelf as it is or unglue them and send for grading? I just don't see any value in those coins.

I have no idea on whether it is real coin or not but what I'm pretty sure is, part (I should say, most) of the coins are not correspondent with the description of the book.

By the way, these coins are really cheap and not necessarily to grade it.

It's quite uncommon to see French posts in English forum.

However, to answer our requester, I'll have to switch between both languages.

The main purpose was concerning the biggest coin he suspected fake (as all ones, but Kenny already answered). He wanted to know which face value do the big coins have.

How would you consider its price, aka. €30?

[Switching back to French][Retour au français]

Dans tous les cas, il s'agit probablement de monnaies authentiques, mais de valeur quasi-nulle. Au contraire, on peut soupçonner que certaines ont été nettoyées.

De plus, contrairement à Donkey, les pièces ne correspondent pas aux monnaies mentionnées sur le dépliant.

Un débat est en cours concernant la nécessité de détruire le dépliant afin d'évaluer lesdites monnaies, ce qui semble peu utile au vu de leur faible valeur.

In my opinion the "big coin" is a "decoration" rather than for circulation. Hence, they have no face value and mostly looked decorative.


In ancient Chinese world, they like to make coin-shaped decoration to enhance "wealth" and "profitability" (that's part of Fung Shui)

BTW, I'm non-French speaker, appreciated for translate and deliver my idea to requester.

In simple words: a charm?

Citeer: "chomp-master"​In simple words: a charm?

Yes it is. My brain functioned not very well today, I can't load up this word.

thanks to all of you for these information, now i understand little coins are original one and the big one is a decoration. If somebody has a better info about this big coin, it will be super. I cleaned this coin, have a look of the new picture, maybe you could tell me what is writing on it ?
best regards

Citeer: "benylyon"​thanks to all of you for these information, now i understand little coins are original one and the big one is a decoration. If somebody has a better info about this big coin, it will be super. I cleaned this coin, have a look of the new picture, maybe you could tell me what is writing on it ?
​best regards
​

​The left side of the picture is "The Eight Trigrams" (八卦)

The right side of the picture is "Chinese Zodiac" (十二生肖), which comprises of 12 Chinese Characters representing the year, and 12 animals

hope this help,

and by the way, this coin can be commonly purchased for 10CNY

thanks a lot for all these informations!
So i understand this big coin is not old one, and could be find today, only the other are old.
Beny