One banknote per page

6 berichten • 63 keer bekeken
Hi there!

I don't know if this topic have been discussed before but we should have only one banknote type per page and under that type we should have all the different variants, years, dates, etc. Here is an example of what I consider is a mistake: Argentina 1 Peso. In this page there are two different banknotes listed: P-287 and P-293, Those are very similar but different notes. The 2019 Standard Catalog of World Paper Money 1961-Present lists them as two separate and different notes and the same principle should be follow in Numista.

I'd like to get your opinion about this.

Regardss,
Elier
The only difference between them is the signature. Is not that important for a new entry in my opinion.
Citeer: "allexis"​The only difference between them is the signature. Is not that important for a new entry in my opinion.
That's not the point. It's not about which are the differences and if it is only the signature, the color or some other minor detail. The point is they are two different notes listed as two different entities in the Standard Catalog of World Paper Money so they should be listed in two separate pages in Numista. ​
Alright, but... we are not the Standard Catalog of World Paper Money. We do not have to follow that catalogue, and we can always group numbers if we think that is better. No worries there. We split pages based on banknote types--not based on external references.

So... aside from signatures, slight shade changes, or external references, are there any major differences between P#287 and P#293?
Citeer: "Sulfur"​Alright, but... we are not the Standard Catalog of World Paper Money. We do not have to follow that catalogue, and we can always group numbers if we think that is better. No worries there. We split pages based on banknote types--not based on external references.

​So... aside from signatures, slight shade changes, or external references, are there any major differences between P#287 and P#293?
​Yes, there are. Note P-287 reads "LEY 18.188" while P-293 reads "DECRETO-LEY No 18.188/69". Something similar happen with the following pairs (all from Argentina):

- P-288/P-294: 5 Pesos
- P-289/P-295: 10 Pesos
- P-290/P-296: 50 Pesos
- P-291/P-297: 100 Pesos
- P-292/P-298: 500 Pesos
All of that can be added in the comments for each type.
Topic verplaatst naar "Numista banknote catalog" (ZacUK, 6-mei-2020, 12:32)

» Forumbeleid

Gebruikte tijdzone is UCT+2:00.
Huidige tijd is 07:15.